Lori Loughlin is bringing Garage Sale Mystery back to Hallmark Channel, and it’s coming sooner than fans might think. The actress announced the revival in a video shared to Instagram, telling fans the long-running mystery series will return sometime this fall 2026, airing first on Hallmark Channel with episodes available the next day on Hallmark+.
For more on Loughlin’s Hallmark comeback, check out FLN’s coverage of her surprise return to When Calls the Heart.
“Hi everyone, I am so excited to announce that we are bringing Garage Sale Mystery back,” Loughlin said in the clip. “It’ll be coming your way sometime this fall. You can watch it on Hallmark Channel and Hallmark+ the next day.”
Hallmark’s own social post teased the news with a similarly playful tone, asking fans to watch for “something mysterious” coming this fall and confirming Loughlin’s return alongside the streaming details.
Garage Sale Mystery originally ran for 16 films between 2013 and 2020, with Loughlin starring throughout as Jennifer Shannon, an antiques dealer with an uncanny knack for stumbling into murder investigations. The series was a steady fixture on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries before production was halted following Loughlin’s 2019 legal troubles. A 17th film, reportedly titled Three Little Murders, was nearly finished filming at the time but never aired.
Watch Loughlin’s full announcement on Instagram here.
This revival comes on the heels of another major Loughlin announcement. She recently confirmed she will return to When Calls the Heart next season as Abigail Stanton, following a surprise cameo at the end of Season 13. Between that comeback and now the Garage Sale Mystery news, Loughlin’s relationship with Hallmark appears to be fully back on.
Fans have actually been pushing for this for months. Reddit threads calling for a Garage Sale Mystery reboot picked up steam earlier this year after Loughlin’s WCTH cameo aired, with longtime viewers saying the mystery series deserved a second life. It looks like someone at Hallmark was paying attention.
No title, cast details beyond Loughlin, or exact premiere date have been announced yet. FLN will update this article as more details roll out.
Lori Loughlin’s Garage Sale Mystery Returns to Hallmark Channel Fall 2026
