The Justice Warriors Return For ‘True Justice: Eye for an Eye’ in May on Hallmark Channel. Katherine McNamara and Markian Tarasiuk are returning for the second movie in the Hallmark Mystery series. ‘True Justice: Eye for an Eye’ will premiere on May 23rd on Hallmark Channel. The cast is back for the second go-around, including Nikki DeLoach and Benjamin Ayres.
True Justice’s third move has already been announced, and is tentatively titled “Lost Love”. When we know more, we will let you know, until then you can follow along with all the Hallmark Channel coverage for 2026.
‘True Justice: Family Ties’ premiered in 2024, and two sequels were announced. This first one will tell the story of when Sharon Warner, President of Penn Charter’s Parent School Coalition, is convicted for the vehicular homicide of a fellow PSC member, the Justice Warriors take a trip back to high school to exonerate a wrongfully convicted wife, mother, and passionate student advocate.
Markian Tarasiuk reprised his role as Eli Flint in the most recent Hallmark Channel movie, ‘Nelly Knows Mysteries: All Manners of Murder.’ ‘True Justice: Eye for an Eye’ is written by Nikki DeLoach and Megan McNulty. Lisa Soper directs it.
May will also see the premiere of ‘Best Served Cold: A Hannah Swenson Mystery’ on May 16th, starring Alison Sweeney and Victor Webster. ‘Sugar & Spice: A Hannah Swensen Mystery‘ aired last month.
Even though the Hallmark Mystery Channel is kinda inactive, it is still nice to know that we, as the audience, are still getting our fix of Hallmark Mysteries
The Justice Warriors Return For ‘True Justice: Eye for an Eye’ in May on Hallmark Channel
