Our Holiday Playbook, the new Hallmark Channel Christmas movie starring Taylor Cole and Charles Michael Davis, premieres tonight, Friday, November 20, at 8 p.m. ET during week six of Countdown to Christmas 2026, and it streams tomorrow on Hallmark+. This weekend of Countdown to Christmas kicks off with football and baking, and this movie will settle whether you prefer meet cutes or origin stories. It follows last weekend’s My Christmas Cowboy, The Nights Before Christmas and Mistletoe and Mimosas.
What Happens in Our Holiday Playbook?
Cole plays Lexi Bell, who comes home for the holidays and has to face a family tradition she would rather skip: the Bell Bowl, a fiercely competitive Christmas flag football game between her dad and her uncle that has fueled decades of sibling rivalry. When her brother-in-law gets hurt, it looks like her family’s losing streak is going to continue. To give them a fighting chance, Lexi makes a deal with Eddie, played by Davis, a former local football star who is now a teacher. She will use her baking skills to help him beat his brother in their annual bake-off if he poses as her boyfriend and meets the “eligibility requirement” to play on her family’s team. As they make their way through each other’s family gatherings and traditions, what started as a deal starts to feel less and less like pretend, and no matter who takes home the trophy, Lexi may have already won at love.
Picture two brothers who make their kids play football every Christmas and two brothers who have a bake-off for their grandmom every Christmas. Lexi and Eddie figure out they can help each other win. Lexi’s dad and uncle remind me of the brothers who coached against each other in Little Giants. Eddie’s grandmom is a diva of a food critic, and Grandma is an icon! Who would not want to impress her? Cole and Davis have an easy, playful chemistry. Whether they are baking, playing football or giving each other detailed backstories to convince everyone they are dating, they are great in scenes together. Cole has been a delight every time we have talked with her this year, from our interview to the Hallmark Christmas Cruise, where she grabbed my phone to say hello to Greg.
My favorite thing in this movie is the meet cute versus origin story debate. For some reason, it clicked with me. Romcom lovers prefer a meet cute. For those who do not know, a meet cute is the moment two people first meet in a romcom, usually in an adorable or unusual way. An origin story usually comes from superhero movies and explains how the superhero became a superhero. You decide which one you prefer to call it.
Steven Sessions wrote Our Holiday Playbook, and it is cleverly written. He has written plenty of Hallmark movies, including one of my favorites, North to Home. Terry Ingram directed, and the football and baking scenes alone are worth the kudos. Ingram also directed A Season to Blossom earlier this year and all three Three Wise Men movies. The baking has a real-world tie-in, too. Bob’s Red Mill partnered on the movie, and its Orange Brown Butter Madeleines are one of the key recipes in the story. “We hope viewers are inspired to watch the movie, make the recipe,” said Daniel Barba, the company’s chief commercial officer. Hallmark fans, look out for a special cameo. Bart is played by a special guest!
How to Watch Our Holiday Playbook
Our Holiday Playbook premieres Friday, November 20, at 8 p.m. ET and 7 p.m. CT on Hallmark Channel, and it streams Saturday, November 21, on Hallmark+. Hallmark Channel also has encores on Saturday, November 21, at 4 p.m. ET, Wednesday, November 25, at 10 p.m. ET and Monday, November 30, at 4 p.m. ET. Find every review in our Countdown to Christmas 2026 hub